“Hey! We need to talk about the website, I have something important for the homepage.”
That is a good welcome. I step into my customer’s office and someone immediately exclaims, “Hey!” and wants to talk. I can feel how enthusiastic they are about the website.
But hold your horses. Why the homepage?
A typical thought is that the homepage is the most important, relevant place to publish something. And no, it is not.
This is typical mistake number one.
Accepting this as a solution is the second mistake. As UX designers we have to ask and understand the need, explain why it may not be right for the homepage, and offer a better alternative. We are not hired to mark the task as done.
So, why not the homepage?
I would not simply answer no, even though 99% of the time I hear this request, the solution is something different. Understanding is the key point here. So let us see what happens.
Users arrive at a homepage and decide within a few seconds whether it is for them. We have to put the right cues in place so they continue and find their way through our proposal.
Put simply, users ask:
• Is this for me?
• Is this what I need?
• Do I like it?
• Do I trust it?
Then conversion happens.
So, even though the temptation is big and virtual space is unlimited, we should not place things wherever the customer wants, even less so when they break the user’s flow, because we damage conversion.
Another thing to consider is cognitive load. If everything is important, nothing is. Imagine attention is money: as soon as the user faces the screen, they start spending their attention budget. A smart thing to do is to place the most important things first. But what is the most important? And here comes the third typical mistake. That one thing is not the new masterclass, nor the new CEO or the company anniversary. It is the one thing the user is looking for.
We have to answer “Is this for me?” and continue until they trust enough to convert.
As surprising as this may sound, all these mistakes can be solved by doing the same thing: user testing. With only five users, you can show your customer what happens when you have unnecessary information on a homepage or landing page.
Contextual user testing is as old as UX itself, inexpensive and quick. The benefits outweigh the effort by far.
We can face long conversations around a subject and have our customer think we do not want to do what they need. Who needs a dissatisfied customer?
Instead, we can show what happens. Put the announcement on the homepage and watch five people use it. Most will scroll past it to find what they came for. Your customer sees this live, and then we can have a good conversation about the place where the new announcement fits better.